Skip to content
12 Axes Test
Portrait of Grover Cleveland

Twenty-second and twenty-fourth US president

Grover Cleveland’s political views

The only president to serve two non-consecutive terms, known for his record number of vetoes, his defence of the gold standard and his call to cut the tariff.

Presidency
22nd and 24th, 1885–1889 and 1893–1897
Party
Democratic
Lived
1837–1908
Scored on
8 of 12 axes

Strongest documented leanings

  1. Privatize80%
  2. Assimilationist75%
  3. Laissez-faire72%
Where Cleveland stood on the twelve axes
Take the quiz

Where Cleveland stood on the twelve axes

Each bar is one axis, between its two poles. Only axes with a documented position are scored; the others are shown as faint stubs on the icon and listed below, never as neutral.

Based on his vetoes, his 1887 tariff message and his response to the Pullman strike. The one social-issue score rests on a single essay written after he left office.

  • Federal vs UnitaryUnitary 55%
    FederalUnitary

    Sent federal troops into Chicago in June 1894 over Governor Altgeld’s protest, but read federal powers narrowly when he vetoed relief spending.

  • Nationalism vs InternationalismNationalism 65%
    NationalismInternationalism

    Endorsed “entangling alliance with none” in 1885, and in 1895 told Congress to resist British claims in the Venezuela boundary dispute, while accepting arbitration.

  • Militarist vs PacifistPacifist 50%
    MilitaristPacifist

    Withdrew the Hawaii annexation treaty in 1893 and declared neutrality in Cuba in 1895, yet his Navy Secretary won five new battleships in 1895–96.

  • Assimilationist vs MulticulturalistAssimilationist 75%
    AssimilationistMulticulturalist

    Signed the Dawes Act, which broke up tribal land into individual allotments, and the Scott Act of 1888, which barred Chinese immigrants who had left the country from returning.

  • Collectivize vs PrivatizePrivatize 80%
    CollectivizePrivatize

    Vetoed hundreds of private pension bills and, in February 1887, the Texas Seed Bill, finding “no warrant” in the Constitution for relief spending.

  • Planned vs Laissez-faireLaissez-faire 72%
    PlannedLaissez-faire

    Signed the Interstate Commerce Act in 1887, but called Congress into special session in 1893 to repeal the Sherman Silver Purchase Act and defend the gold standard.

  • Isolationism vs GlobalismGlobalism 70%
    IsolationismGlobalism

    Devoted his entire 1887 annual message to cutting the tariff, though he let the modest Wilson–Gorman tariff of 1894 become law unsigned.

  • Progressive vs TraditionalTraditional 70%
    ProgressiveTraditional

    Argued against women’s suffrage in a 1905 Ladies’ Home Journal article.

No documented position, so not scored: Democratic vs Autocratic, Security vs Freedom, Irreligious vs Religious, and Acceleration vs Bioconservative.

What shaped the scores

Dated actions from the record. Each is tied to the axis it informs.

  1. Cleveland vetoes the Texas Seed Bill, finding no warrant in the Constitution for relief spending.

    Collectivize vs Privatize

    First presidency of Grover Cleveland · Wikipedia
  2. His annual message, given over entirely to the tariff, calls for lower duties.

    Isolationism vs Globalism

    First presidency of Grover Cleveland · Wikipedia
  3. He withdraws the Hawaii annexation treaty from the Senate five days after taking office for his second term.

    Militarist vs Pacifist

    Second presidency of Grover Cleveland · Wikipedia
  4. He calls Congress into special session to repeal the Sherman Silver Purchase Act and defend the gold standard.

    Planned vs Laissez-faire

    Second presidency of Grover Cleveland · Wikipedia
  5. He sends federal troops into Chicago and 20 other rail centres during the Pullman strike, over Governor Altgeld’s protest.

    Federal vs Unitary

    Second presidency of Grover Cleveland · Wikipedia
  6. He tells Congress that the United States must resist any British attempt to take territory in the Venezuela boundary dispute, and asks for a commission to study it.

    Nationalism vs Internationalism

    Venezuelan crisis of 1895 · Wikipedia

Cleveland compared with other presidents

Measured on the axes both presidents are scored on, with the same rules as the quiz.

Questions about Grover Cleveland’s politics

The only president to serve two non-consecutive terms, known for his record number of vetoes, his defence of the gold standard and his call to cut the tariff. On our twelve axes, the strongest documented leanings are Privatize 80%, Assimilationist 75%, Laissez-faire 72%.

Those labels changed meaning over time, so this site describes Cleveland on twelve axes instead. On the economy, Cleveland’s record leans toward free markets and private provision. On social questions it leans traditional. The scores above give the evidence behind each axis.

Grover Cleveland was a Democrat. Cleveland was the 22nd and 24th president, serving 1885–1889 and 1893–1897.

On the axes they are both scored on, Cleveland is closest to Andrew Jackson, Calvin Coolidge, John Adams and furthest from Lyndon B. Johnson, Franklin D. Roosevelt, Harry S. Truman.

In his first term he vetoed hundreds of private pension bills for Civil War veterans, reasoning that Congress should not override the Pension Bureau’s rejections, and in February 1887 he vetoed the Texas Seed Bill, saying he could find no warrant for it in the Constitution.

Something else on your mind? Get in touch

How close are you to Cleveland?

Take the test and see how your twelve scores compare, axis by axis.