Skip to content
12 Axes Test
Portrait of Herbert Hoover

Thirty-first US president

Herbert Hoover’s political views

The thirty-first president, who signed the Smoot–Hawley Tariff, created the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, resisted direct federal relief and ordered the Bonus Army’s camp cleared.

Presidency
31st, 1929–1933
Party
Republican
Lived
1874–1964
Scored on
7 of 12 axes

Strongest documented leanings

  1. Isolationism88%
  2. Assimilationist75%
  3. Security72%
Where Hoover stood on the twelve axes
Take the quiz

Where Hoover stood on the twelve axes

Each bar is one axis, between its two poles. Only axes with a documented position are scored; the others are shown as faint stubs on the icon and listed below, never as neutral.

Based on his record from 1929 to 1933, during the first years of the Great Depression. His earlier work on famine relief is not scored.

  • Security vs FreedomSecurity 72%
    SecurityFreedom

    Ordered the Army to clear the Bonus Army’s camp in Washington in July 1932, where General MacArthur led infantry and cavalry supported by six tanks.

  • Nationalism vs InternationalismInternationalism 55%
    NationalismInternationalism

    Proposed the war-debt moratorium of 1931 and, with Secretary of State Stimson, set out the policy of not recognising Japan’s conquest of Manchuria.

  • Militarist vs PacifistPacifist 72%
    MilitaristPacifist

    Signed the London Naval Treaty in 1930, ended the occupation of Nicaragua and proposed a one-year halt to Allied war debt payments in 1931.

  • Assimilationist vs MulticulturalistAssimilationist 75%
    AssimilationistMulticulturalist

    In 1930 ordered that immigrants must have a job before arriving, and his administration oversaw the deportation and repatriation of Mexicans from 1930 to 1932.

  • Collectivize vs PrivatizePrivatize 62%
    CollectivizePrivatize

    Held that local governments and private giving should meet individuals’ needs and vetoed a bill for direct federal lending to individuals, though he signed the Emergency Relief and Construction Act in July 1932.

  • Planned vs Laissez-fairePlanned 52%
    PlannedLaissez-faire

    Created the Federal Farm Board in June 1929 and the Reconstruction Finance Corporation in January 1932, but relied on voluntary cooperation by business rather than federal direction; the record points both ways.

  • Isolationism vs GlobalismIsolationism 88%
    IsolationismGlobalism

    Signed the Smoot–Hawley Tariff in June 1930, which raised duties on over 20,000 imported goods, after more than a thousand economists petitioned him to veto it.

No documented position, so not scored: Federal vs Unitary, Democratic vs Autocratic, Irreligious vs Religious, Progressive vs Traditional, and Acceleration vs Bioconservative.

What shaped the scores

Dated actions from the record. Each is tied to the axis it informs.

  1. Hoover signs the Agricultural Marketing Act, which creates the Federal Farm Board.

    Planned vs Laissez-faire

    Presidency of Herbert Hoover · Wikipedia
  2. He signs the Smoot–Hawley Tariff despite a petition from more than a thousand economists.

    Isolationism vs Globalism

    Smoot–Hawley Tariff Act · Wikipedia
  3. The United States signs the London Naval Treaty limiting warship tonnage.

    Militarist vs Pacifist

    Presidency of Herbert Hoover · Wikipedia
  4. Congress creates the Reconstruction Finance Corporation at Hoover’s urging.

    Planned vs Laissez-faire

    Presidency of Herbert Hoover · Wikipedia
  5. He signs the Federal Home Loan Bank Act and the Emergency Relief and Construction Act.

    Collectivize vs Privatize

    Presidency of Herbert Hoover · Wikipedia
  6. Army troops under General MacArthur clear the Bonus Army’s camp in Washington.

    Security vs Freedom

    Bonus Army · Wikipedia

Hoover compared with other presidents

Measured on the axes both presidents are scored on, with the same rules as the quiz.

Questions about Herbert Hoover’s politics

The thirty-first president, who signed the Smoot–Hawley Tariff, created the Reconstruction Finance Corporation, resisted direct federal relief and ordered the Bonus Army’s camp cleared. On our twelve axes, the strongest documented leanings are Isolationism 88%, Assimilationist 75%, Security 72%.

Those labels changed meaning over time, so this site describes Hoover on twelve axes instead. On the economy, Hoover’s record sits between government action and free markets. The scores above give the evidence behind each axis.

Herbert Hoover was a Republican. Hoover was the 31st president, serving 1929–1933.

On the axes they are both scored on, Hoover is closest to Ulysses S. Grant, George Washington, John Adams and furthest from James K. Polk, Lyndon B. Johnson, Harry S. Truman.

No. He created the Federal Farm Board in 1929 and the Reconstruction Finance Corporation in 1932 and signed a relief and construction act in July 1932, but he opposed direct federal relief to individuals and vetoed a bill for direct federal lending to them.

Something else on your mind? Get in touch

Sources and credits

How close are you to Hoover?

Take the test and see how your twelve scores compare, axis by axis.