Skip to content
12 Axes Test

Bioconservatism

Bioconservatism holds that human nature and biology should not be fundamentally altered by technology, and urges caution about genetic engineering, enhancement and life extension.

How close are you to Bioconservatism?

Take the test and your match with Bioconservatism shows up here. It is worked out in your browser and never sent anywhere.

Your alignment--%
Agree onTop 3 axes
Differ onKey gaps

What is Bioconservatism?

Bioconservatives are not against medicine or technology as such. They argue that using it to redesign human beings, for example through germline editing or radical enhancement, could undermine human dignity, equality and the shared basis of morality.

The label covers thinkers on both left and right: religious conservatives, but also environmentalists and critics of technology.

What are the core ideas of Bioconservatism?

The ideas that most people in this tradition would sign up to.

  • Respect for human nature and dignity
  • Precaution about genetic modification and enhancement
  • Concern about inequality between the enhanced and the unenhanced
  • Support for treating disease, but not for redesigning humanity

Where does Bioconservatism come from?

The term came into use in the early 2000s in debates with transhumanists, with thinkers such as Leon Kass, Francis Fukuyama and Jürgen Habermas making related arguments.

Which historical thinkers are closest to Bioconservatism?

Thinkers whose documented positions on the 12 axes align most closely with this ideology.

Isaiah Berlin

Isaiah Berlin

Oxford political theorist · 1909–1997

A Riga-born Oxford scholar who distinguished negative from positive liberty and argued that human values are plural and can conflict without any master ranking.

Closest aligned axisDemocratic vs Autocratic

“Constitutional democracy guards against monistic tyranny while accommodating value pluralism.”

Nelson Mandela

Nelson Mandela

South African president · 1918–2013

A South African lawyer imprisoned for 27 years for his part in the fight against apartheid, who became the first president elected by all South Africans in 1994.

Closest aligned axisMilitarist vs Pacifist

“Co-founded the armed wing of the ANC and defended sabotage at Rivonia, but as president chose reconciliation over retribution.”

Montesquieu

Montesquieu

French political theorist · 1689–1755

A French jurist whose Spirit of the Laws compared forms of government and argued that liberty is safest where power is divided among separate institutions.

Closest aligned axisSecurity vs Freedom

“Liberty is the right to do what the laws permit, free from arbitrary state fear.”

Where does Bioconservatism sit on the 12 axes?

These are its strongest leanings, followed by all twelve axes. They describe the typical version of the tradition.

Strongest leanings

Governmental

Federal vs Unitary
Federal 50%50% Unitary
Democratic vs Autocratic
Democratic 80%20% Autocratic
Security vs Freedom
Security 30%70% Freedom

Diplomatic

Nationalism vs Internationalism
Nationalism 45%55% Internationalism
Militarist vs Pacifist
Militarist 40%60% Pacifist
Assimilationist vs Multiculturalist
Assimilationist 50%50% Multiculturalist

Economic

Collectivize vs Privatize
Collectivize 50%50% Privatize
Planned vs Laissez-faire
Planned 50%50% Laissez-faire
Isolationism vs Globalism
Isolationism 50%50% Globalism

Societal

Irreligious vs Religious
Irreligious 50%50% Religious
Progressive vs Traditional
Progressive 35%65% Traditional
Acceleration vs Bioconservative
Acceleration 2%98% Bioconservative

Editorial estimates for comparison and discussion. Real people and parties in this tradition vary.

Which countries are closest to Bioconservatism?

Countries whose estimated profile is most like this ideology. No country follows a single ideology, so read this as a comparison, not a label.

What are the main criticisms of Bioconservatism?

Every tradition has critics. These are the objections most often raised.

  • Critics argue that the line between treatment and enhancement is blurry and that restrictions could block beneficial medicine.
  • Others say that “human nature” is not a fixed thing.

Bioconservatism: frequently asked questions

Bioconservatism holds that human nature and biology should not be fundamentally altered by technology, and urges caution about genetic engineering, enhancement and life extension.

It depends on the question, because left and right mix several things. On the 12 axes, Bioconservatism sits closest to a mix of public and private on economics and to traditional values on social values.

By estimated profile, the closest are Italy, Namibia, and Nepal. No country follows one ideology purely, so treat this as a comparison, not a label.

Critics argue that the line between treatment and enhancement is blurry and that restrictions could block beneficial medicine. Others say that “human nature” is not a fixed thing.

Take the 12 axes test. It scores you on twelve axes and shows how closely your profile matches Bioconservatism and every other ideology on this site. The calculation happens in your browser.

Something else on your mind? Get in touch

Do you agree with Bioconservatism?

The test scores you on all twelve axes and ranks every ideology by how well it matches you.